Skip to main content

Review of Shadowlands by Moulton Players at Moulton Theatre, Northampton

It has to be said that the world of Narnia, as created by C. S. Lewis, generally passed me by when I was young. My childhood reading generally came more from the more crazy side like Roald Dahl, therefore I have neither read, or I believe, ever seen any interpretation of Narnia. Not to say that my knowledge doesn't reach to the famous wardrobe, which in its way, has a curious, but fulfilling existence, in William Nicholson's Shadowlands as well.

Shadowlands deals with the relationship between C. S. Lewis and American writer Jo Gresham (Davidman), from burgeoning, to love and then her sudden illness. It's a lovely endearing and gentle tale, which in this production from Moulton Players, is mostly successful, albeit it occasionally clunky, especially in its very long first act.

As C. S. Lewis, Alex Page-Bailey gives a confident performance in a very large role. It has to be said, it doesn't start well, as the play opens with a long, and ponderous lecture to the audience, as part of Lewis' world of Christian apologist. It's a horrid, relentless opening to a play, that frankly deserves better. It also has to be said that it isn't Page-Bailey's finest moment, as the delivery of this piece has limited life in it, making it feel much longer as a result. It's curious that the second act opens with a similar scene directed right at the audience, and here, the emotion pulls through and the whole speech is pushed right through the audience as a result. More of that energy at the start of the first act would have been a delight. During the standard play, away from lecturing though, Page-Bailey is great, full of the slow building emotion, of a man who has reached almost sixty, seemingly never truly loved before.

Joy Davidson is played in a solid, confident way by Louise Drage, instilling much of the emotion into the role. She is definitely a chilly character at times, and you have to wonder, especially in the overlong first act, what actually makes Lewis so captivated by her (albeit, underlying at this stage). However, by the second half, the emotion and connections are much greater, because the relationship has become more lighthearted and carefree, ironic considering the turn of events.

Much of the enjoyment of this play comes from the second act, the first is woefully overlong and at times ponderous, but, the second act pays of for the patience of its audience with some lovely scenes between Davidson and Lewis.

There are other nice performances in this production beyond the two leads, Iain Gillies gives more life than the one-dimensional character of Major W. H. Lewis (Warnie) almost deserves. It's underwritten and quite characterless in dialogue, but Gillies breathes life into the role, including his simple, silent reactions garnering much audience appreciation.

Peter Laughton is great as the sharp and rude Professor Riley, happy to state his opinion of Lewis' new lady, but not so keen to take Joy's rebuff, simply performed, but entertaining at all times. Andrew Wintersgill also entertains, disgracefully stealing a scene from under the noses of the leads, with his, more than willing to sample the drinks, waiter.

Finally, special mention must go to Charlie Leonard-Pepin for a truly delightful little performance as Joy's son, Douglas (curiously Shadowlands dispenses totally with her second son, David). He is a wonderful presence on stage and exhibits everything of a star of the future, never switching off on stage, even when just in the background.

The play at times doesn't allow itself to be overly dynamic, with quite a few scenes rooted to locations with little chance of movement, however, director Stephen Loveless does keep the play moving with locations created simply by simply locking them to fixed places upon the stage and effective lighting changes. It allows the play to flow surprisingly well. The wardrobe of the centre stage is nicely realised also, becoming a character of its own.

Shadowlands is a sweet play, and in this production, nicely performed. There is no question for me that it is far too long, with the first act outstaying its welcome by a good ten minutes at least. However, the sharper, much more entertaining second act makes up for much of the disappointment of the first and leaves the audience entertained, despite the nature of the play.

Performance reviewed: Monday 5th March, 2018 at Moulton Theatre, Northampton

Shadowlands runs at Moulton Theatre, Northampton until Saturday 10th March 2018

For full details of the Moulton Theatre visit their website at


Popular posts from this blog

Review of Shrek the Musical at Royal & Derngate (Derngate), Northampton

When Shrek the Musical rolls into town, it arrives in seven great big lorries, and this actually says a little as to where the strength of this production, now well into its UK tour, lies. This show looks spectacular in every way, it might be the best looking and the biggest tour show you will have ever seen. However, at times, this spectacle feels a little superficial, as you feel more thought could have been put into the original writing.

Shrek the Musical mostly follows the story of the original 2001 computer-animated film, which sees ogre Shrek's swamp overrun by fairytale folk, which results in him confronting the evil Lord Farquaad, which then results in him going to rescue Princess Fiona, as you do.

What feels missing though in this musical (book by David Lindsay-Abaire and music by Jeanine Tesori), compared with the film, is the clever balance for children and adults alike. This nearly always feels targeted more at adults, there is a lack of humour that feels just right fo…

Review of Glorious! from White Cobra Productions at The Playhouse Theatre, Northampton

I don't mind admitting that I am a huge fan of the work of White Cobra Productions, they have the ability to draw together the best of what the local amateur world has to offer and package it together in a professional way, they also have a knack for picking plays of quality, rarely performed or brand new material that makes them a breath of fresh air. Well mostly. I don't mind also admitting once again here, that their last show, Hi-de-Hi, felt a terrible misstep on their part, taking a show which was either so enrooted in the minds of some of its audience to single performers of the past, or a bamboozled collection of dated material to others, just didn't really work despite the talent and obvious effort of its cast. So, what of Glorious!, is this a, ahem, glorious return to form?
Short answer, incredibly so, long answer, below.
Glorious! (subtitled The Worst Singer in the World) tells the true story of Florence Foster Jenkins, an American socialite, active in the early …

Review of A Bunch Of Amateurs at Stantonbury Theatre, Milton Keynes

I first saw the film of A Bunch of Amateurs a couple of years ago back when I was purely a watcher of amateurs productions, rather than my now, slightly more involved persona. Therefore watching this production by Etc Theatre of this curious tale of country folk, adapted for the stage by two of the original writers Ian Hislop and Nick Newman, and their amateur dramatics world, offers a little more intrigue than that film first did. It also helped that I was seated with a bevy of knowing amateur dramatics folks as well.

Stratford Players are in trouble, their venue is under threat from developers, so, in a last-ditch attempt to save their group, they send appeals out to the big names of the acting world to help generate lifesaving interest. Answering their appeal is the also in trouble, Hollywood actor Jefferson Steel (Bart Gamber). His flagging career sees him accept the opportunity to perform King Lear, in the home of the Bard itself, Stratford. Sadly it turns out to be a barn theat…